A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

    Abstract

    This paper argues that the modern barn in Ireland is a complex social and architectural phenomena that is without, or has yet to find, a satisfactory discourse. Emerging in the middle third of the twentieth century, the modern barn – replete with corrugated iron and I-sections – continues to represent a presence in the Irish landscape whose ubiquity is as emphatic as its flexibility. It is, however, its universal properties that begin to suggest connections with wider narratives. The modernising aspects of the barn that appear in the 1920s and 30s begin to conflate with a rhetoric of architectural modernism which was simultaneously appearing across Europe. But while the relationship between high modernism’s critique of what it divined as the inspirational qualities of utilitarian buildings – Walter Gropius on grain silos, Le Corbusier on aircraft hangers etc. – has been well-documented, in Ireland this relationship perhaps contains another layer of complexity.
    The barn’s consolidation as a modern type coincided with the search for a nation’s cultural identity after centuries of colonial rule. This tended to be an introspective vision that prioritised rural space over urban space, agriculture over industry, and imagined the small farm as a central tenet in the construction of a new State. This paper suggests that the twentieth-century barn – as a product of the mechanisation of agriculture promoted by the new administrations – is an iconic structure, emblematic of attempts to reconcile the contradictory forces and imagery of modernity with the mores of a traditional society. Moreover, given a cultural purview that was often ambivalent or even hostile to the ideologies and forms of modernity, the barn in Ireland is, perhaps, not so much the inspiration but the realisation of an architectural modernism in that country at its most pervasive, enduring and unself-conscious.
    LanguageEnglish
    Number of pages10
    Publication statusPublished - Apr 2010
    EventSociety of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting - Chicago, United States
    Duration: 15 Apr 201018 Apr 2010

    Conference

    ConferenceSociety of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting
    CountryUnited States
    CityChicago
    Period15/04/201018/04/2010

    Fingerprint

    Modernity
    Ireland
    Agriculture
    Colonial Rule
    Industry
    Discourse
    Urban Space
    Rhetoric
    High Modernism
    Iron
    Iconic
    1920s
    Walter Gropius
    Emphatics
    Contradictory
    Farm
    Silo
    Ideology
    Appearings
    Conscious

    Cite this

    Boyd, G. (2010). A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland. Paper presented at Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting, Chicago, United States.
    Boyd, Gary. / A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland. Paper presented at Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting, Chicago, United States.10 p.
    @conference{f9d2d9515f2541568cdb2cb193ea1a62,
    title = "A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland",
    abstract = "This paper argues that the modern barn in Ireland is a complex social and architectural phenomena that is without, or has yet to find, a satisfactory discourse. Emerging in the middle third of the twentieth century, the modern barn – replete with corrugated iron and I-sections – continues to represent a presence in the Irish landscape whose ubiquity is as emphatic as its flexibility. It is, however, its universal properties that begin to suggest connections with wider narratives. The modernising aspects of the barn that appear in the 1920s and 30s begin to conflate with a rhetoric of architectural modernism which was simultaneously appearing across Europe. But while the relationship between high modernism’s critique of what it divined as the inspirational qualities of utilitarian buildings – Walter Gropius on grain silos, Le Corbusier on aircraft hangers etc. – has been well-documented, in Ireland this relationship perhaps contains another layer of complexity.The barn’s consolidation as a modern type coincided with the search for a nation’s cultural identity after centuries of colonial rule. This tended to be an introspective vision that prioritised rural space over urban space, agriculture over industry, and imagined the small farm as a central tenet in the construction of a new State. This paper suggests that the twentieth-century barn – as a product of the mechanisation of agriculture promoted by the new administrations – is an iconic structure, emblematic of attempts to reconcile the contradictory forces and imagery of modernity with the mores of a traditional society. Moreover, given a cultural purview that was often ambivalent or even hostile to the ideologies and forms of modernity, the barn in Ireland is, perhaps, not so much the inspiration but the realisation of an architectural modernism in that country at its most pervasive, enduring and unself-conscious.",
    author = "Gary Boyd",
    year = "2010",
    month = "4",
    language = "English",
    note = "Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting ; Conference date: 15-04-2010 Through 18-04-2010",

    }

    Boyd, G 2010, 'A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland' Paper presented at Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting, Chicago, United States, 15/04/2010 - 18/04/2010, .

    A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland. / Boyd, Gary.

    2010. Paper presented at Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting, Chicago, United States.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

    TY - CONF

    T1 - A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland

    AU - Boyd, Gary

    PY - 2010/4

    Y1 - 2010/4

    N2 - This paper argues that the modern barn in Ireland is a complex social and architectural phenomena that is without, or has yet to find, a satisfactory discourse. Emerging in the middle third of the twentieth century, the modern barn – replete with corrugated iron and I-sections – continues to represent a presence in the Irish landscape whose ubiquity is as emphatic as its flexibility. It is, however, its universal properties that begin to suggest connections with wider narratives. The modernising aspects of the barn that appear in the 1920s and 30s begin to conflate with a rhetoric of architectural modernism which was simultaneously appearing across Europe. But while the relationship between high modernism’s critique of what it divined as the inspirational qualities of utilitarian buildings – Walter Gropius on grain silos, Le Corbusier on aircraft hangers etc. – has been well-documented, in Ireland this relationship perhaps contains another layer of complexity.The barn’s consolidation as a modern type coincided with the search for a nation’s cultural identity after centuries of colonial rule. This tended to be an introspective vision that prioritised rural space over urban space, agriculture over industry, and imagined the small farm as a central tenet in the construction of a new State. This paper suggests that the twentieth-century barn – as a product of the mechanisation of agriculture promoted by the new administrations – is an iconic structure, emblematic of attempts to reconcile the contradictory forces and imagery of modernity with the mores of a traditional society. Moreover, given a cultural purview that was often ambivalent or even hostile to the ideologies and forms of modernity, the barn in Ireland is, perhaps, not so much the inspiration but the realisation of an architectural modernism in that country at its most pervasive, enduring and unself-conscious.

    AB - This paper argues that the modern barn in Ireland is a complex social and architectural phenomena that is without, or has yet to find, a satisfactory discourse. Emerging in the middle third of the twentieth century, the modern barn – replete with corrugated iron and I-sections – continues to represent a presence in the Irish landscape whose ubiquity is as emphatic as its flexibility. It is, however, its universal properties that begin to suggest connections with wider narratives. The modernising aspects of the barn that appear in the 1920s and 30s begin to conflate with a rhetoric of architectural modernism which was simultaneously appearing across Europe. But while the relationship between high modernism’s critique of what it divined as the inspirational qualities of utilitarian buildings – Walter Gropius on grain silos, Le Corbusier on aircraft hangers etc. – has been well-documented, in Ireland this relationship perhaps contains another layer of complexity.The barn’s consolidation as a modern type coincided with the search for a nation’s cultural identity after centuries of colonial rule. This tended to be an introspective vision that prioritised rural space over urban space, agriculture over industry, and imagined the small farm as a central tenet in the construction of a new State. This paper suggests that the twentieth-century barn – as a product of the mechanisation of agriculture promoted by the new administrations – is an iconic structure, emblematic of attempts to reconcile the contradictory forces and imagery of modernity with the mores of a traditional society. Moreover, given a cultural purview that was often ambivalent or even hostile to the ideologies and forms of modernity, the barn in Ireland is, perhaps, not so much the inspiration but the realisation of an architectural modernism in that country at its most pervasive, enduring and unself-conscious.

    M3 - Paper

    ER -

    Boyd G. A box in the field: modernity and the barn in twentieth-century Ireland. 2010. Paper presented at Society of Architectural Historians (SAH) 63rd Annual Meeting, Chicago, United States.