A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment

Jianjun Tang, W George Hutchinson, Ruth Hunter, Susan Chilton , Morten Lau, Frank Kee

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

21 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

A comprehensive understanding of individual-level discounting behaviours is crucial because of its implications for designing financial incentive interventions encouraging health behaviors. This paper estimates mixture models to determine probabilistically the discounting functional form which has the best fit to discounting behaviours, on the basis of a series of incentive-compatible time and risk preference field experiments conducted among 176 civil servants in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Time preference was structurally estimated while controlling for risk preference, background consumption, and probability weighting. The results suggested that future monetary incentives were discounted hyperbolically rather than exponentially and that a generalised hyperbolic form had the best fit among a series of alternative functional forms. Our results also showed that the failure to adopt an appropriate type of functional form led to significantly different discount rates and misleading associations between time preference and real-world behaviours such as smoking. Identifying the best-fit discounting functional form may be a useful tool to improve the effectiveness of financial incentive interventions such that more immediate rewards should be provided to the target population with a higher degree of time-inconsistency.Keywords: Hyperbolic discounting; Time preference; Risk preference; Mixture models; Smoking
Original languageEnglish
Pages1 - 32
Number of pages32
Publication statusPublished - 06 Sep 2017
EventEconomic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 - Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien Vienna university of economics and Business, Vienna, Austria
Duration: 06 Sep 201709 Sep 2017
Conference number: 2017
http://esa2017.wu.ac.at/

Conference

ConferenceEconomic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9
Abbreviated titleESA European Meeting
CountryAustria
CityVienna
Period06/09/201709/09/2017
Internet address

Fingerprint

Discounting
Time preference
Functional form
Field experiment
Risk preferences
Mixture model
Financial incentives
Smoking
Incentive compatible
Key words
Discount rate
Time inconsistency
Reward
Northern Ireland
Monetary incentives
Civil servants
Probability weighting
Hyperbolic discounting

Cite this

Tang, J., Hutchinson, W. G., Hunter, R., Chilton , S., Lau, M., & Kee, F. (2017). A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment. 1 - 32. Paper presented at Economic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 , Vienna, Austria.
Tang, Jianjun ; Hutchinson, W George ; Hunter, Ruth ; Chilton , Susan ; Lau, Morten ; Kee, Frank. / A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment. Paper presented at Economic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 , Vienna, Austria.32 p.
@conference{a6e15e474b4f43e3b7265a982a9faa64,
title = "A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment",
abstract = "A comprehensive understanding of individual-level discounting behaviours is crucial because of its implications for designing financial incentive interventions encouraging health behaviors. This paper estimates mixture models to determine probabilistically the discounting functional form which has the best fit to discounting behaviours, on the basis of a series of incentive-compatible time and risk preference field experiments conducted among 176 civil servants in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Time preference was structurally estimated while controlling for risk preference, background consumption, and probability weighting. The results suggested that future monetary incentives were discounted hyperbolically rather than exponentially and that a generalised hyperbolic form had the best fit among a series of alternative functional forms. Our results also showed that the failure to adopt an appropriate type of functional form led to significantly different discount rates and misleading associations between time preference and real-world behaviours such as smoking. Identifying the best-fit discounting functional form may be a useful tool to improve the effectiveness of financial incentive interventions such that more immediate rewards should be provided to the target population with a higher degree of time-inconsistency.Keywords: Hyperbolic discounting; Time preference; Risk preference; Mixture models; Smoking",
author = "Jianjun Tang and Hutchinson, {W George} and Ruth Hunter and Susan Chilton and Morten Lau and Frank Kee",
year = "2017",
month = "9",
day = "6",
language = "English",
pages = "1 -- 32",
note = "Economic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 , ESA European Meeting ; Conference date: 06-09-2017 Through 09-09-2017",
url = "http://esa2017.wu.ac.at/",

}

Tang, J, Hutchinson, WG, Hunter, R, Chilton , S, Lau, M & Kee, F 2017, 'A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment', Paper presented at Economic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 , Vienna, Austria, 06/09/2017 - 09/09/2017 pp. 1 - 32.

A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment. / Tang, Jianjun; Hutchinson, W George ; Hunter, Ruth; Chilton , Susan ; Lau, Morten ; Kee, Frank.

2017. 1 - 32 Paper presented at Economic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 , Vienna, Austria.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment

AU - Tang, Jianjun

AU - Hutchinson, W George

AU - Hunter, Ruth

AU - Chilton , Susan

AU - Lau, Morten

AU - Kee, Frank

PY - 2017/9/6

Y1 - 2017/9/6

N2 - A comprehensive understanding of individual-level discounting behaviours is crucial because of its implications for designing financial incentive interventions encouraging health behaviors. This paper estimates mixture models to determine probabilistically the discounting functional form which has the best fit to discounting behaviours, on the basis of a series of incentive-compatible time and risk preference field experiments conducted among 176 civil servants in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Time preference was structurally estimated while controlling for risk preference, background consumption, and probability weighting. The results suggested that future monetary incentives were discounted hyperbolically rather than exponentially and that a generalised hyperbolic form had the best fit among a series of alternative functional forms. Our results also showed that the failure to adopt an appropriate type of functional form led to significantly different discount rates and misleading associations between time preference and real-world behaviours such as smoking. Identifying the best-fit discounting functional form may be a useful tool to improve the effectiveness of financial incentive interventions such that more immediate rewards should be provided to the target population with a higher degree of time-inconsistency.Keywords: Hyperbolic discounting; Time preference; Risk preference; Mixture models; Smoking

AB - A comprehensive understanding of individual-level discounting behaviours is crucial because of its implications for designing financial incentive interventions encouraging health behaviors. This paper estimates mixture models to determine probabilistically the discounting functional form which has the best fit to discounting behaviours, on the basis of a series of incentive-compatible time and risk preference field experiments conducted among 176 civil servants in Belfast, Northern Ireland. Time preference was structurally estimated while controlling for risk preference, background consumption, and probability weighting. The results suggested that future monetary incentives were discounted hyperbolically rather than exponentially and that a generalised hyperbolic form had the best fit among a series of alternative functional forms. Our results also showed that the failure to adopt an appropriate type of functional form led to significantly different discount rates and misleading associations between time preference and real-world behaviours such as smoking. Identifying the best-fit discounting functional form may be a useful tool to improve the effectiveness of financial incentive interventions such that more immediate rewards should be provided to the target population with a higher degree of time-inconsistency.Keywords: Hyperbolic discounting; Time preference; Risk preference; Mixture models; Smoking

M3 - Paper

SP - 1

EP - 32

ER -

Tang J, Hutchinson WG, Hunter R, Chilton S, Lau M, Kee F. A comparison of time preference functional forms: Evidence from a field experiment. 2017. Paper presented at Economic Science Association:European Meeting 2017 Vienna September 6-9 , Vienna, Austria.