An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

When the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs opened a limited daily postal service to the general public in 1878, it issued the first postage stamps produced by the Chinese government. As well as a means of payment, these postage stamps were visual and tangible representations of the issuing authority. Not previously considered in detail by historians, the first Customs Post issue precipitated a struggle for control among the foreign officials of the Maritime Customs which arose from significant disagreements over both communications and globalisation in China. Robert Hart and James Campbell sought to use the new postal service to situate China within Western-dominated global norms of governance and administration, while Gustav Detring’s focus was on expansion of Chinese communication networks. These conflicting objectives spilled into disagreements over the design of the first stamp, which were eventually resolved by the Large Dragons. The stamp dispute initiated deep divisions over authority within the Maritime Customs as Detring’s relationship with Hart deteriorated, and Detring’s role as Li Hongzhang’s advisor expanded. The episode also illustrates the diverse and sometimes contradictory approaches to Chinese reform among Westerners in the late Qing, and their complex alignments with Chinese authorities and Western interests.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty
EditorsChengzhang Xie, Haiyong Li
PublisherChina National Post and Postage Stamp Museum
Pages150-170
Number of pages21
Publication statusPublished - 04 Aug 2018

Publication series

NameJiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama
ISSN (Print)1002-5898

Fingerprint

Authority
Dragon
Stamp
China
Communication
Postage Stamps
Globalization
Westerners
Government
Contradictory
Historian
James Campbell
General Public
Dispute
Governance
Alignment

Keywords

  • Qing postal system
  • Imperial Maritime Customs
  • Robert Hart
  • Gustav Detring
  • Large Dragon stamp
  • globalisation

Cite this

Reisz, E. (2018). An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp. In C. Xie, & H. Li (Eds.), The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty (pp. 150-170). (Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama). China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum.
Reisz, Emma. / An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp. The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty. editor / Chengzhang Xie ; Haiyong Li. China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum, 2018. pp. 150-170 (Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama).
@inbook{0a89abf670b249fa82e46708abb4cae1,
title = "An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp",
abstract = "When the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs opened a limited daily postal service to the general public in 1878, it issued the first postage stamps produced by the Chinese government. As well as a means of payment, these postage stamps were visual and tangible representations of the issuing authority. Not previously considered in detail by historians, the first Customs Post issue precipitated a struggle for control among the foreign officials of the Maritime Customs which arose from significant disagreements over both communications and globalisation in China. Robert Hart and James Campbell sought to use the new postal service to situate China within Western-dominated global norms of governance and administration, while Gustav Detring’s focus was on expansion of Chinese communication networks. These conflicting objectives spilled into disagreements over the design of the first stamp, which were eventually resolved by the Large Dragons. The stamp dispute initiated deep divisions over authority within the Maritime Customs as Detring’s relationship with Hart deteriorated, and Detring’s role as Li Hongzhang’s advisor expanded. The episode also illustrates the diverse and sometimes contradictory approaches to Chinese reform among Westerners in the late Qing, and their complex alignments with Chinese authorities and Western interests.",
keywords = "Qing postal system, Imperial Maritime Customs, Robert Hart, Gustav Detring, Large Dragon stamp, globalisation",
author = "Emma Reisz",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "4",
language = "English",
series = "Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama",
publisher = "China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum",
pages = "150--170",
editor = "Chengzhang Xie and Haiyong Li",
booktitle = "The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty",

}

Reisz, E 2018, An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp. in C Xie & H Li (eds), The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty. Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama, China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum, pp. 150-170.

An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp. / Reisz, Emma.

The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty. ed. / Chengzhang Xie; Haiyong Li. China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum, 2018. p. 150-170 (Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp

AU - Reisz, Emma

PY - 2018/8/4

Y1 - 2018/8/4

N2 - When the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs opened a limited daily postal service to the general public in 1878, it issued the first postage stamps produced by the Chinese government. As well as a means of payment, these postage stamps were visual and tangible representations of the issuing authority. Not previously considered in detail by historians, the first Customs Post issue precipitated a struggle for control among the foreign officials of the Maritime Customs which arose from significant disagreements over both communications and globalisation in China. Robert Hart and James Campbell sought to use the new postal service to situate China within Western-dominated global norms of governance and administration, while Gustav Detring’s focus was on expansion of Chinese communication networks. These conflicting objectives spilled into disagreements over the design of the first stamp, which were eventually resolved by the Large Dragons. The stamp dispute initiated deep divisions over authority within the Maritime Customs as Detring’s relationship with Hart deteriorated, and Detring’s role as Li Hongzhang’s advisor expanded. The episode also illustrates the diverse and sometimes contradictory approaches to Chinese reform among Westerners in the late Qing, and their complex alignments with Chinese authorities and Western interests.

AB - When the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs opened a limited daily postal service to the general public in 1878, it issued the first postage stamps produced by the Chinese government. As well as a means of payment, these postage stamps were visual and tangible representations of the issuing authority. Not previously considered in detail by historians, the first Customs Post issue precipitated a struggle for control among the foreign officials of the Maritime Customs which arose from significant disagreements over both communications and globalisation in China. Robert Hart and James Campbell sought to use the new postal service to situate China within Western-dominated global norms of governance and administration, while Gustav Detring’s focus was on expansion of Chinese communication networks. These conflicting objectives spilled into disagreements over the design of the first stamp, which were eventually resolved by the Large Dragons. The stamp dispute initiated deep divisions over authority within the Maritime Customs as Detring’s relationship with Hart deteriorated, and Detring’s role as Li Hongzhang’s advisor expanded. The episode also illustrates the diverse and sometimes contradictory approaches to Chinese reform among Westerners in the late Qing, and their complex alignments with Chinese authorities and Western interests.

KW - Qing postal system

KW - Imperial Maritime Customs

KW - Robert Hart

KW - Gustav Detring

KW - Large Dragon stamp

KW - globalisation

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

T3 - Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama

SP - 150

EP - 170

BT - The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty

A2 - Xie, Chengzhang

A2 - Li, Haiyong

PB - China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum

ER -

Reisz E. An Issue of Authority Robert Hart, Gustav Detring and the Large Dragon Stamp. In Xie C, Li H, editors, The Large Dragon Stamp and the Customs Post of the Qing dynasty. China National Post and Postage Stamp Museum. 2018. p. 150-170. (Jiyou Bolan = Philatelic Panorama).