Between Enabling and provider approach:Key shifts in the national housing policy in India and Brazil

Urmi Sengupta, Brendan Murtagh, Camila D'Ottaviano, Suzana Pasternak

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)
406 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

With the world becoming increasingly urban, housing poverty in the global south has made the metaphor ‘planet of slums’ a global reality. This paper revisits the dichotomy of enabler vs. provider debate in housing policy that preoccupied housing scholars in the last few decades. Drawing on the government intervention in Brazil and India, it is argued that the transformative and adaptive capacity of enabling strategy has now come of an age. Among other things, the paper makes a close reading of the historical and geographical (re)constitution of the process of housing delivery in these countries and argues that they have adopted enabling strategies along with closely intertwined strategies of crisis management and show a clear predisposition towards earlier provider approach of state administered, large-scale housing programmes to support the low-income households. Thus, as one policy approach follows another, the discursive space for the government policy doctrine acquires a layered structure, which contains elements of both provider and enabling approaches. Whilst these developments, still evolutionary, challenges remain in the form of conceptual contradictions that continue to obscure our approach towards low-income housing policies in the global South. Arguably on this basis, considerably more, attention should be given to providing housing to the poor in the global South.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)856-876
Number of pages21
JournalEnvironment and Planning C: Politics and Space
Volume36
Issue number5
Early online date21 Jul 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01 Aug 2018

Fingerprint

housing policy
Brazil
housing
India
low income housing
urban housing
crisis management
household income
poverty
low income
planet
slum
government policy
doctrine
metaphor
constitution
management
world
housing programme

Cite this

@article{9857b49fd8a140bd8bd7bed7c130a2db,
title = "Between Enabling and provider approach:Key shifts in the national housing policy in India and Brazil",
abstract = "With the world becoming increasingly urban, housing poverty in the global south has made the metaphor ‘planet of slums’ a global reality. This paper revisits the dichotomy of enabler vs. provider debate in housing policy that preoccupied housing scholars in the last few decades. Drawing on the government intervention in Brazil and India, it is argued that the transformative and adaptive capacity of enabling strategy has now come of an age. Among other things, the paper makes a close reading of the historical and geographical (re)constitution of the process of housing delivery in these countries and argues that they have adopted enabling strategies along with closely intertwined strategies of crisis management and show a clear predisposition towards earlier provider approach of state administered, large-scale housing programmes to support the low-income households. Thus, as one policy approach follows another, the discursive space for the government policy doctrine acquires a layered structure, which contains elements of both provider and enabling approaches. Whilst these developments, still evolutionary, challenges remain in the form of conceptual contradictions that continue to obscure our approach towards low-income housing policies in the global South. Arguably on this basis, considerably more, attention should be given to providing housing to the poor in the global South.",
author = "Urmi Sengupta and Brendan Murtagh and Camila D'Ottaviano and Suzana Pasternak",
year = "2018",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/2399654417725754",
language = "English",
volume = "36",
pages = "856--876",
journal = "Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space",
issn = "2399-6544",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "5",

}

Between Enabling and provider approach:Key shifts in the national housing policy in India and Brazil. / Sengupta, Urmi; Murtagh, Brendan; D'Ottaviano, Camila; Pasternak, Suzana.

In: Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space, Vol. 36, No. 5, 01.08.2018, p. 856-876.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Between Enabling and provider approach:Key shifts in the national housing policy in India and Brazil

AU - Sengupta, Urmi

AU - Murtagh, Brendan

AU - D'Ottaviano, Camila

AU - Pasternak, Suzana

PY - 2018/8/1

Y1 - 2018/8/1

N2 - With the world becoming increasingly urban, housing poverty in the global south has made the metaphor ‘planet of slums’ a global reality. This paper revisits the dichotomy of enabler vs. provider debate in housing policy that preoccupied housing scholars in the last few decades. Drawing on the government intervention in Brazil and India, it is argued that the transformative and adaptive capacity of enabling strategy has now come of an age. Among other things, the paper makes a close reading of the historical and geographical (re)constitution of the process of housing delivery in these countries and argues that they have adopted enabling strategies along with closely intertwined strategies of crisis management and show a clear predisposition towards earlier provider approach of state administered, large-scale housing programmes to support the low-income households. Thus, as one policy approach follows another, the discursive space for the government policy doctrine acquires a layered structure, which contains elements of both provider and enabling approaches. Whilst these developments, still evolutionary, challenges remain in the form of conceptual contradictions that continue to obscure our approach towards low-income housing policies in the global South. Arguably on this basis, considerably more, attention should be given to providing housing to the poor in the global South.

AB - With the world becoming increasingly urban, housing poverty in the global south has made the metaphor ‘planet of slums’ a global reality. This paper revisits the dichotomy of enabler vs. provider debate in housing policy that preoccupied housing scholars in the last few decades. Drawing on the government intervention in Brazil and India, it is argued that the transformative and adaptive capacity of enabling strategy has now come of an age. Among other things, the paper makes a close reading of the historical and geographical (re)constitution of the process of housing delivery in these countries and argues that they have adopted enabling strategies along with closely intertwined strategies of crisis management and show a clear predisposition towards earlier provider approach of state administered, large-scale housing programmes to support the low-income households. Thus, as one policy approach follows another, the discursive space for the government policy doctrine acquires a layered structure, which contains elements of both provider and enabling approaches. Whilst these developments, still evolutionary, challenges remain in the form of conceptual contradictions that continue to obscure our approach towards low-income housing policies in the global South. Arguably on this basis, considerably more, attention should be given to providing housing to the poor in the global South.

U2 - 10.1177/2399654417725754

DO - 10.1177/2399654417725754

M3 - Article

VL - 36

SP - 856

EP - 876

JO - Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space

JF - Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space

SN - 2399-6544

IS - 5

ER -