Enquiring about traumatic experiences in psychosis: A comparison of case notes and self-report questionnaires

Twylla Cunningham*, Ciaran Shannon, Ivor Crothers, Katrina Hoy, Carly Fitzsimmons, Riona McCann, John O’Hare, Ciaran Mulholland

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose: Studies have found an association between a history of trauma and the presence of psychotic symptoms. Despite the research evidence it appears to be the case that many clinicians are not routinely asking about traumatic experiences. This study aims to ascertain the level of agreement between rates of self-reported trauma and that which is recorded in case notes.

Methods: The study population was drawn from all individuals with a confirmed diagnosis of psychosis, residing within a defined catchment area. Rates of childhood trauma, lifetime trauma and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland recorded in participants’ case notes were compared to their responses on self-report questionnaires: THQ, CTQ and TREQ.

Results: Relatively high levels of trauma were reported by participants on the self-report measures that were administered. The rates of trauma recorded in case note records were similar to that found in other studies. Also in line with other research were poor levels of agreement between self-report and case note data.

Conclusion: High levels of lifetime, childhood and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland were found when the individuals in the sample were directly assessed for the purposes of this study. In contrast much lower rates were recorded in patient notes on routine clinical assessment. The results suggest that clinicians do not routinely enquire about trauma histories with this population and as a result, case notes underestimate trauma prevalence.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)301-310
Number of pages10
JournalPsychosis: Psychological, Social and Integrative Approaches
Volume8
Issue number4
Early online date08 Jan 2016
DOIs
Publication statusEarly online date - 08 Jan 2016

Fingerprint

Psychotic Disorders
Self Report
Wounds and Injuries
Northern Ireland
Surveys and Questionnaires
Research
Population

Keywords

  • case note analysis
  • psychosis
  • self-report
  • trauma

Cite this

Cunningham, Twylla ; Shannon, Ciaran ; Crothers, Ivor ; Hoy, Katrina ; Fitzsimmons, Carly ; McCann, Riona ; O’Hare, John ; Mulholland, Ciaran. / Enquiring about traumatic experiences in psychosis: A comparison of case notes and self-report questionnaires. In: Psychosis: Psychological, Social and Integrative Approaches. 2016 ; Vol. 8, No. 4. pp. 301-310.
@article{ea4d2d09e2d8476bb4d96c20ed3220ab,
title = "Enquiring about traumatic experiences in psychosis: A comparison of case notes and self-report questionnaires",
abstract = "Purpose: Studies have found an association between a history of trauma and the presence of psychotic symptoms. Despite the research evidence it appears to be the case that many clinicians are not routinely asking about traumatic experiences. This study aims to ascertain the level of agreement between rates of self-reported trauma and that which is recorded in case notes. Methods: The study population was drawn from all individuals with a confirmed diagnosis of psychosis, residing within a defined catchment area. Rates of childhood trauma, lifetime trauma and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland recorded in participants’ case notes were compared to their responses on self-report questionnaires: THQ, CTQ and TREQ. Results: Relatively high levels of trauma were reported by participants on the self-report measures that were administered. The rates of trauma recorded in case note records were similar to that found in other studies. Also in line with other research were poor levels of agreement between self-report and case note data. Conclusion: High levels of lifetime, childhood and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland were found when the individuals in the sample were directly assessed for the purposes of this study. In contrast much lower rates were recorded in patient notes on routine clinical assessment. The results suggest that clinicians do not routinely enquire about trauma histories with this population and as a result, case notes underestimate trauma prevalence.",
keywords = "case note analysis, psychosis, self-report, trauma",
author = "Twylla Cunningham and Ciaran Shannon and Ivor Crothers and Katrina Hoy and Carly Fitzsimmons and Riona McCann and John O’Hare and Ciaran Mulholland",
year = "2016",
month = "1",
day = "8",
doi = "10.1080/17522439.2015.1115542",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "301--310",
journal = "Psychosis: Psychological, Social and Integrative Approaches",
issn = "1752-2439",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "4",

}

Enquiring about traumatic experiences in psychosis: A comparison of case notes and self-report questionnaires. / Cunningham, Twylla; Shannon, Ciaran; Crothers, Ivor; Hoy, Katrina; Fitzsimmons, Carly; McCann, Riona; O’Hare, John; Mulholland, Ciaran.

In: Psychosis: Psychological, Social and Integrative Approaches, Vol. 8, No. 4, 08.01.2016, p. 301-310.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Enquiring about traumatic experiences in psychosis: A comparison of case notes and self-report questionnaires

AU - Cunningham, Twylla

AU - Shannon, Ciaran

AU - Crothers, Ivor

AU - Hoy, Katrina

AU - Fitzsimmons, Carly

AU - McCann, Riona

AU - O’Hare, John

AU - Mulholland, Ciaran

PY - 2016/1/8

Y1 - 2016/1/8

N2 - Purpose: Studies have found an association between a history of trauma and the presence of psychotic symptoms. Despite the research evidence it appears to be the case that many clinicians are not routinely asking about traumatic experiences. This study aims to ascertain the level of agreement between rates of self-reported trauma and that which is recorded in case notes. Methods: The study population was drawn from all individuals with a confirmed diagnosis of psychosis, residing within a defined catchment area. Rates of childhood trauma, lifetime trauma and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland recorded in participants’ case notes were compared to their responses on self-report questionnaires: THQ, CTQ and TREQ. Results: Relatively high levels of trauma were reported by participants on the self-report measures that were administered. The rates of trauma recorded in case note records were similar to that found in other studies. Also in line with other research were poor levels of agreement between self-report and case note data. Conclusion: High levels of lifetime, childhood and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland were found when the individuals in the sample were directly assessed for the purposes of this study. In contrast much lower rates were recorded in patient notes on routine clinical assessment. The results suggest that clinicians do not routinely enquire about trauma histories with this population and as a result, case notes underestimate trauma prevalence.

AB - Purpose: Studies have found an association between a history of trauma and the presence of psychotic symptoms. Despite the research evidence it appears to be the case that many clinicians are not routinely asking about traumatic experiences. This study aims to ascertain the level of agreement between rates of self-reported trauma and that which is recorded in case notes. Methods: The study population was drawn from all individuals with a confirmed diagnosis of psychosis, residing within a defined catchment area. Rates of childhood trauma, lifetime trauma and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland recorded in participants’ case notes were compared to their responses on self-report questionnaires: THQ, CTQ and TREQ. Results: Relatively high levels of trauma were reported by participants on the self-report measures that were administered. The rates of trauma recorded in case note records were similar to that found in other studies. Also in line with other research were poor levels of agreement between self-report and case note data. Conclusion: High levels of lifetime, childhood and trauma related to the Troubles in Northern Ireland were found when the individuals in the sample were directly assessed for the purposes of this study. In contrast much lower rates were recorded in patient notes on routine clinical assessment. The results suggest that clinicians do not routinely enquire about trauma histories with this population and as a result, case notes underestimate trauma prevalence.

KW - case note analysis

KW - psychosis

KW - self-report

KW - trauma

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84953742773&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1080/17522439.2015.1115542

DO - 10.1080/17522439.2015.1115542

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84953742773

VL - 8

SP - 301

EP - 310

JO - Psychosis: Psychological, Social and Integrative Approaches

JF - Psychosis: Psychological, Social and Integrative Approaches

SN - 1752-2439

IS - 4

ER -