Exploiting Conditionality: EU and International Actors and post-NPM Reform in Ireland

Muiris MacCarthaigh*, Niamh Hardiman

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to specialist publicationArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
94 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Between 2008-15 Ireland undertook unprecedented and systemic public sector reforms in a polity not traditionally considered a prominent reformer. While some of these reforms comprised part of the loan programme agreement with EU and international actors, many others did not. This article argues that the crisis in Ireland provided a window of opportunity to introduce reforms that political and administrative elites had previously found difficult to implement. The authority of the Troika was invoked to provide legitimacy for controversial initiatives, yet some of the reforms went further than the loan programme strictly required. A number of these concerning organisational rationalisation, the public service ‘bargain’ and transversal policy coordination, are considered here. Agreements were negotiated with public sector unions that facilitated sharp cuts in pay and conditions, reducing the potential for opposition to change. The reform effort was further legitimated by the reformers’ post-NPM, whole-of-government discourse, which situated considerations of effectiveness and efficiency in a broader framework of public service quality and delivery.
Original languageEnglish
Specialist publicationPublic Policy and Administration
PublisherSAGE
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019

Fingerprint

Ireland
EU
reform
loan
public service
public sector
political reform
rationalization
legitimacy
opposition
elite
efficiency
discourse

Keywords

  • Global financial crisis
  • Ireland
  • post-New Public Management
  • public sector reform
  • Troika

Cite this

@misc{fb4d221310bb40568529cdddbf5d8887,
title = "Exploiting Conditionality: EU and International Actors and post-NPM Reform in Ireland",
abstract = "Between 2008-15 Ireland undertook unprecedented and systemic public sector reforms in a polity not traditionally considered a prominent reformer. While some of these reforms comprised part of the loan programme agreement with EU and international actors, many others did not. This article argues that the crisis in Ireland provided a window of opportunity to introduce reforms that political and administrative elites had previously found difficult to implement. The authority of the Troika was invoked to provide legitimacy for controversial initiatives, yet some of the reforms went further than the loan programme strictly required. A number of these concerning organisational rationalisation, the public service ‘bargain’ and transversal policy coordination, are considered here. Agreements were negotiated with public sector unions that facilitated sharp cuts in pay and conditions, reducing the potential for opposition to change. The reform effort was further legitimated by the reformers’ post-NPM, whole-of-government discourse, which situated considerations of effectiveness and efficiency in a broader framework of public service quality and delivery.",
keywords = "Global financial crisis, Ireland, post-New Public Management, public sector reform, Troika",
author = "Muiris MacCarthaigh and Niamh Hardiman",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1177/0952076718796548",
language = "English",
journal = "Public Policy and Administration",
issn = "0952-0767",
publisher = "SAGE",

}

Exploiting Conditionality: EU and International Actors and post-NPM Reform in Ireland. / MacCarthaigh, Muiris; Hardiman, Niamh.

In: Public Policy and Administration, 2019.

Research output: Contribution to specialist publicationArticle

TY - GEN

T1 - Exploiting Conditionality: EU and International Actors and post-NPM Reform in Ireland

AU - MacCarthaigh, Muiris

AU - Hardiman, Niamh

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Between 2008-15 Ireland undertook unprecedented and systemic public sector reforms in a polity not traditionally considered a prominent reformer. While some of these reforms comprised part of the loan programme agreement with EU and international actors, many others did not. This article argues that the crisis in Ireland provided a window of opportunity to introduce reforms that political and administrative elites had previously found difficult to implement. The authority of the Troika was invoked to provide legitimacy for controversial initiatives, yet some of the reforms went further than the loan programme strictly required. A number of these concerning organisational rationalisation, the public service ‘bargain’ and transversal policy coordination, are considered here. Agreements were negotiated with public sector unions that facilitated sharp cuts in pay and conditions, reducing the potential for opposition to change. The reform effort was further legitimated by the reformers’ post-NPM, whole-of-government discourse, which situated considerations of effectiveness and efficiency in a broader framework of public service quality and delivery.

AB - Between 2008-15 Ireland undertook unprecedented and systemic public sector reforms in a polity not traditionally considered a prominent reformer. While some of these reforms comprised part of the loan programme agreement with EU and international actors, many others did not. This article argues that the crisis in Ireland provided a window of opportunity to introduce reforms that political and administrative elites had previously found difficult to implement. The authority of the Troika was invoked to provide legitimacy for controversial initiatives, yet some of the reforms went further than the loan programme strictly required. A number of these concerning organisational rationalisation, the public service ‘bargain’ and transversal policy coordination, are considered here. Agreements were negotiated with public sector unions that facilitated sharp cuts in pay and conditions, reducing the potential for opposition to change. The reform effort was further legitimated by the reformers’ post-NPM, whole-of-government discourse, which situated considerations of effectiveness and efficiency in a broader framework of public service quality and delivery.

KW - Global financial crisis

KW - Ireland

KW - post-New Public Management

KW - public sector reform

KW - Troika

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85064550902&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0952076718796548

DO - 10.1177/0952076718796548

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85064550902

JO - Public Policy and Administration

JF - Public Policy and Administration

SN - 0952-0767

PB - SAGE

ER -