Abstract
Purpose
To assess how key stakeholders, including visually impaired individuals and ophthalmic professionals, perceive potential challenges and effects on visually impaired users navigating the built environment
Methods
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 20 stakeholders including 3 town planners, 4 architects, 3 visually impaired individuals, 6 ophthalmic professionals including ophthalmologists and optometrists and 4 sight loss charities. All transcripts were analysed using NVivo version 11 and random transcripts from each category were analysed by a secondary analyst, to agree on themes and sub-themes. A senior researcher adjudicated themes and subthemes.
Results
Four main themes and twenty-three subthemes were identified (table 1). The main themes included barriers and enablers of the built environment, the impact of living with visual impairment, policy, regulation and guidance and future solutions and innovations. The issues mentioned most were isolation and loneliness (33 times), confidence (21 times), mental health (19 times), independence (13 times). This was echoed by all stakeholders with planning professionals stating, ‘it must restrict them going out psychologically which leads to a lack of interaction, makes them homebound which impacts their physical and mental health and wellbeing’. Charities stated that ‘People [feel] cut off from the rest of society stuck at home’. In addition, some of the biggest barriers and enablers to navigating the built environment were issues with pavements (58 times), street furniture (36 times), lighting (25 times), shared space (18 times) and pedestrian crossings (17 times). Visually impaired individuals felt that ‘we give so much space to cars and everyone else has to jostle on the pavement in fear of their death’. Town planners and architects echoed these concerns commenting ‘far too much space has been given over to the motor vehicle and now the space on footways in restricted’.
Conclusions
This study showed that there are potential challenges for people with a visual impairment when navigating the built environment, many of which ophthalmic professionals, built environment professionals, charities and visually impaired people agreed on. The results also showed how big an impact having visual impairment can have on moving around towns and cities and its effect on mental and physical health.
To assess how key stakeholders, including visually impaired individuals and ophthalmic professionals, perceive potential challenges and effects on visually impaired users navigating the built environment
Methods
Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 20 stakeholders including 3 town planners, 4 architects, 3 visually impaired individuals, 6 ophthalmic professionals including ophthalmologists and optometrists and 4 sight loss charities. All transcripts were analysed using NVivo version 11 and random transcripts from each category were analysed by a secondary analyst, to agree on themes and sub-themes. A senior researcher adjudicated themes and subthemes.
Results
Four main themes and twenty-three subthemes were identified (table 1). The main themes included barriers and enablers of the built environment, the impact of living with visual impairment, policy, regulation and guidance and future solutions and innovations. The issues mentioned most were isolation and loneliness (33 times), confidence (21 times), mental health (19 times), independence (13 times). This was echoed by all stakeholders with planning professionals stating, ‘it must restrict them going out psychologically which leads to a lack of interaction, makes them homebound which impacts their physical and mental health and wellbeing’. Charities stated that ‘People [feel] cut off from the rest of society stuck at home’. In addition, some of the biggest barriers and enablers to navigating the built environment were issues with pavements (58 times), street furniture (36 times), lighting (25 times), shared space (18 times) and pedestrian crossings (17 times). Visually impaired individuals felt that ‘we give so much space to cars and everyone else has to jostle on the pavement in fear of their death’. Town planners and architects echoed these concerns commenting ‘far too much space has been given over to the motor vehicle and now the space on footways in restricted’.
Conclusions
This study showed that there are potential challenges for people with a visual impairment when navigating the built environment, many of which ophthalmic professionals, built environment professionals, charities and visually impaired people agreed on. The results also showed how big an impact having visual impairment can have on moving around towns and cities and its effect on mental and physical health.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Publication status | Published - 01 May 2022 |
| Event | Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology Annual Meeting 2022 - New Orleans, USA, Denver, United States Duration: 01 May 2022 → 04 May 2022 https://www.arvo.org/annual-meeting/ |
Conference
| Conference | Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology Annual Meeting 2022 |
|---|---|
| Abbreviated title | ARVO 2022 |
| Country/Territory | United States |
| City | Denver |
| Period | 01/05/2022 → 04/05/2022 |
| Internet address |
Fingerprint
Dive into the research topics of 'Navigating the unseen city: stakeholder opinions on navigation of the built environment by visually impaired individuals'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.Student theses
-
The role of the peripheral retina in diabetic retinopathy: from basic science to town planning
Cushley, L. (Author), Galway, N. (Supervisor), Peto, T. (Supervisor) & Hageman, G. (Supervisor), Jul 2023Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis › Doctor of Philosophy
File