To cut a long story short: Formal chronological modelling for the late neolithic site of ness of Brodgar, Orkney

Nick Card, Ingrid Mainland, Scott Timpany, Roy Towers, Cathy Batt, Christopher Bronk Ramsey, Elaine Dunbar, Paula Reimer, Alex Bayliss, Peter Marshall, Alasdair Whittle

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In the context of unanswered questions about the nature and development of the Late Neolithic in Orkney, we present a summary of research up to 2015 on the major site at the Ness of Brodgar, Mainland Orkney, concentrating on the impressive buildings. Finding sufficient samples for radiocarbon dating was a considerable challenge. There are indications, from both features and finds, of activity pre-dating the main set of buildings exposed so far by excavation. Forty-six dates on thirty-nine samples are presented and are interpreted in a formal chronological framework. Two models are presented, reflecting different possible readings of the sequence. Both indicate that piered architecture was in use by the thirtieth century cal bc and that the massive Structure 10, not the first building in the sequence, was also in existence by the thirtieth century cal bc. Activity associated with piered architecture came to an end (in Model 2) around 2800 cal bc. Midden and rubble infill followed. After an appreciable interval, the hearth at the centre of Structure 10 was last used around 2500 cal bc, perhaps the only activity in an otherwise abandoned site. The remains of some 400 or more cattle were deposited over the ruins of Structure 10: In Model 2, in the mid-twenty-fifth century cal bc, but in Model 1 in the late twenty-fourth or twenty-third century cal bc. The chronologies invite comparison with the near-neighbour of Barnhouse, in use from the later thirty-second to the earlier twenty-ninth century cal bc, and the Stones of Stenness, probably erected by the thirtieth century cal bc. The Ness, including Structure 10, appears to have outlasted Barnhouse, but probably did not endure as long in its primary form as previously envisaged. The decay and decommissioning of the Ness may have coincided with the further development of the sacred landscape around it; but precise chronologies for other sites in the surrounding landscape are urgently required. The spectacular feasting remains of several hundred cattle deposited above Structure 10 may belong to a radically changing world, coinciding (in Model 2) with the appearance of Beakers nationally, but it was arguably the, by now, mythic status of that building which drew people back to it.

LanguageEnglish
Pages217-263
Number of pages47
JournalEuropean Journal of Archaeology
Volume21
Issue number2
Early online date05 Apr 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 01 May 2018

Fingerprint

building
indication
Cut
Short Story
Late Neolithic
Orkney
Modeling
Chronology
Cattle
Beaker
Decay
Summary
Radiocarbon Dating
Excavation
Hearth
Feasting
9th Century
Middens
Third Century
Ruin

Keywords

  • chronologische Modellierung
  • Grooved Ware (gekerbte Ware)
  • Ness of Brodgar
  • Radiokarbon Datierung
  • Spätneolithikum
  • StichworteOrkney

Cite this

Card, Nick ; Mainland, Ingrid ; Timpany, Scott ; Towers, Roy ; Batt, Cathy ; Ramsey, Christopher Bronk ; Dunbar, Elaine ; Reimer, Paula ; Bayliss, Alex ; Marshall, Peter ; Whittle, Alasdair. / To cut a long story short: Formal chronological modelling for the late neolithic site of ness of Brodgar, Orkney. In: European Journal of Archaeology. 2018 ; Vol. 21, No. 2. pp. 217-263.
@article{14adfa584f9e463c88552302c19ff816,
title = "To cut a long story short: Formal chronological modelling for the late neolithic site of ness of Brodgar, Orkney",
abstract = "In the context of unanswered questions about the nature and development of the Late Neolithic in Orkney, we present a summary of research up to 2015 on the major site at the Ness of Brodgar, Mainland Orkney, concentrating on the impressive buildings. Finding sufficient samples for radiocarbon dating was a considerable challenge. There are indications, from both features and finds, of activity pre-dating the main set of buildings exposed so far by excavation. Forty-six dates on thirty-nine samples are presented and are interpreted in a formal chronological framework. Two models are presented, reflecting different possible readings of the sequence. Both indicate that piered architecture was in use by the thirtieth century cal bc and that the massive Structure 10, not the first building in the sequence, was also in existence by the thirtieth century cal bc. Activity associated with piered architecture came to an end (in Model 2) around 2800 cal bc. Midden and rubble infill followed. After an appreciable interval, the hearth at the centre of Structure 10 was last used around 2500 cal bc, perhaps the only activity in an otherwise abandoned site. The remains of some 400 or more cattle were deposited over the ruins of Structure 10: In Model 2, in the mid-twenty-fifth century cal bc, but in Model 1 in the late twenty-fourth or twenty-third century cal bc. The chronologies invite comparison with the near-neighbour of Barnhouse, in use from the later thirty-second to the earlier twenty-ninth century cal bc, and the Stones of Stenness, probably erected by the thirtieth century cal bc. The Ness, including Structure 10, appears to have outlasted Barnhouse, but probably did not endure as long in its primary form as previously envisaged. The decay and decommissioning of the Ness may have coincided with the further development of the sacred landscape around it; but precise chronologies for other sites in the surrounding landscape are urgently required. The spectacular feasting remains of several hundred cattle deposited above Structure 10 may belong to a radically changing world, coinciding (in Model 2) with the appearance of Beakers nationally, but it was arguably the, by now, mythic status of that building which drew people back to it.",
keywords = "chronologische Modellierung, Grooved Ware (gekerbte Ware), Ness of Brodgar, Radiokarbon Datierung, Sp{\"a}tneolithikum, StichworteOrkney",
author = "Nick Card and Ingrid Mainland and Scott Timpany and Roy Towers and Cathy Batt and Ramsey, {Christopher Bronk} and Elaine Dunbar and Paula Reimer and Alex Bayliss and Peter Marshall and Alasdair Whittle",
year = "2018",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1017/eaa.2016.29",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "217--263",
journal = "European Journal of Archaeology",
issn = "1461-9571",
publisher = "Maney Publishing",
number = "2",

}

Card, N, Mainland, I, Timpany, S, Towers, R, Batt, C, Ramsey, CB, Dunbar, E, Reimer, P, Bayliss, A, Marshall, P & Whittle, A 2018, 'To cut a long story short: Formal chronological modelling for the late neolithic site of ness of Brodgar, Orkney', European Journal of Archaeology, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 217-263. https://doi.org/10.1017/eaa.2016.29

To cut a long story short: Formal chronological modelling for the late neolithic site of ness of Brodgar, Orkney. / Card, Nick; Mainland, Ingrid; Timpany, Scott; Towers, Roy; Batt, Cathy; Ramsey, Christopher Bronk; Dunbar, Elaine; Reimer, Paula; Bayliss, Alex; Marshall, Peter; Whittle, Alasdair.

In: European Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 21, No. 2, 01.05.2018, p. 217-263.

Research output: Contribution to journalReview article

TY - JOUR

T1 - To cut a long story short: Formal chronological modelling for the late neolithic site of ness of Brodgar, Orkney

AU - Card, Nick

AU - Mainland, Ingrid

AU - Timpany, Scott

AU - Towers, Roy

AU - Batt, Cathy

AU - Ramsey, Christopher Bronk

AU - Dunbar, Elaine

AU - Reimer, Paula

AU - Bayliss, Alex

AU - Marshall, Peter

AU - Whittle, Alasdair

PY - 2018/5/1

Y1 - 2018/5/1

N2 - In the context of unanswered questions about the nature and development of the Late Neolithic in Orkney, we present a summary of research up to 2015 on the major site at the Ness of Brodgar, Mainland Orkney, concentrating on the impressive buildings. Finding sufficient samples for radiocarbon dating was a considerable challenge. There are indications, from both features and finds, of activity pre-dating the main set of buildings exposed so far by excavation. Forty-six dates on thirty-nine samples are presented and are interpreted in a formal chronological framework. Two models are presented, reflecting different possible readings of the sequence. Both indicate that piered architecture was in use by the thirtieth century cal bc and that the massive Structure 10, not the first building in the sequence, was also in existence by the thirtieth century cal bc. Activity associated with piered architecture came to an end (in Model 2) around 2800 cal bc. Midden and rubble infill followed. After an appreciable interval, the hearth at the centre of Structure 10 was last used around 2500 cal bc, perhaps the only activity in an otherwise abandoned site. The remains of some 400 or more cattle were deposited over the ruins of Structure 10: In Model 2, in the mid-twenty-fifth century cal bc, but in Model 1 in the late twenty-fourth or twenty-third century cal bc. The chronologies invite comparison with the near-neighbour of Barnhouse, in use from the later thirty-second to the earlier twenty-ninth century cal bc, and the Stones of Stenness, probably erected by the thirtieth century cal bc. The Ness, including Structure 10, appears to have outlasted Barnhouse, but probably did not endure as long in its primary form as previously envisaged. The decay and decommissioning of the Ness may have coincided with the further development of the sacred landscape around it; but precise chronologies for other sites in the surrounding landscape are urgently required. The spectacular feasting remains of several hundred cattle deposited above Structure 10 may belong to a radically changing world, coinciding (in Model 2) with the appearance of Beakers nationally, but it was arguably the, by now, mythic status of that building which drew people back to it.

AB - In the context of unanswered questions about the nature and development of the Late Neolithic in Orkney, we present a summary of research up to 2015 on the major site at the Ness of Brodgar, Mainland Orkney, concentrating on the impressive buildings. Finding sufficient samples for radiocarbon dating was a considerable challenge. There are indications, from both features and finds, of activity pre-dating the main set of buildings exposed so far by excavation. Forty-six dates on thirty-nine samples are presented and are interpreted in a formal chronological framework. Two models are presented, reflecting different possible readings of the sequence. Both indicate that piered architecture was in use by the thirtieth century cal bc and that the massive Structure 10, not the first building in the sequence, was also in existence by the thirtieth century cal bc. Activity associated with piered architecture came to an end (in Model 2) around 2800 cal bc. Midden and rubble infill followed. After an appreciable interval, the hearth at the centre of Structure 10 was last used around 2500 cal bc, perhaps the only activity in an otherwise abandoned site. The remains of some 400 or more cattle were deposited over the ruins of Structure 10: In Model 2, in the mid-twenty-fifth century cal bc, but in Model 1 in the late twenty-fourth or twenty-third century cal bc. The chronologies invite comparison with the near-neighbour of Barnhouse, in use from the later thirty-second to the earlier twenty-ninth century cal bc, and the Stones of Stenness, probably erected by the thirtieth century cal bc. The Ness, including Structure 10, appears to have outlasted Barnhouse, but probably did not endure as long in its primary form as previously envisaged. The decay and decommissioning of the Ness may have coincided with the further development of the sacred landscape around it; but precise chronologies for other sites in the surrounding landscape are urgently required. The spectacular feasting remains of several hundred cattle deposited above Structure 10 may belong to a radically changing world, coinciding (in Model 2) with the appearance of Beakers nationally, but it was arguably the, by now, mythic status of that building which drew people back to it.

KW - chronologische Modellierung

KW - Grooved Ware (gekerbte Ware)

KW - Ness of Brodgar

KW - Radiokarbon Datierung

KW - Spätneolithikum

KW - StichworteOrkney

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85041629837&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/eaa.2016.29

DO - 10.1017/eaa.2016.29

M3 - Review article

VL - 21

SP - 217

EP - 263

JO - European Journal of Archaeology

T2 - European Journal of Archaeology

JF - European Journal of Archaeology

SN - 1461-9571

IS - 2

ER -