Awakening Critical Consciousness in General Practice teaching

: Towards a Philosophy of Praxis

  • Annalisa Manca

Student thesis: Doctoral ThesisDoctor of Philosophy

Abstract

Background & Purpose As medicine’s social contract evolves, medical schools have a growing obligation to foster doctors who are conscious of social dynamics and inequality in healthcare, and willing to affect societal change. This approach can be nurtured via the development of a ‘critical consciousness’ (i.e., awareness and questioning) of power and privilege. Although this discourse is increasing in medical education, applying a critical pedagogy within curricula in which competency-based orientations are dominant, is not straightforward because of their different philosophical and theoretical underpinnings. It requires courage towards change from medical educators, and a profound awareness of how context influences educational practices and dynamics. This thesis outlines how the affordances to awaken critical consciousness are enacted in the context of an undergraduate General Practice course. It is about the way GP teachers enact the object of their concern, General Practice, through a series of educational practices in which elements of General Practice are being identified, conceptualised, problematised, deconstructed, given meaning and placed in a social, historical and cultural context. Methodology This qualitative educational research adopted an overarching postcritical ethnographic approach, informed by social constructivist theory, postmodern themes and critical theory. The researcher observed a GP undergraduate course, writing extensive fieldnotes, and interviewed and collected audio-diaries to elicit participants’ viewpoints. Discourse analysis was used to analyse the data in order to answer the question: ‘How are the affordances for the development of critical consciousness enacted, in an undergraduate General Practice learning environment?’ Results The GP teachers, while mitigating hierarchical relations with students, ‘directed’ them by imparting a certain degree of instruction. They cultivated students’ understanding of General Practice through their educational practices and through their teaching of values, rather than the teaching of skills for immediate practical purposes. Their educational approach acknowledged students’ ‘spontaneity’, while pursuing ‘conscious direction’ (Gramsci, 1992). The educational practices guided students into ‘reading the world’ (Freire & Macedo, 1987) of General Practice and medicine in general. This involved the observation of the practical social context and the recognition of social issues, an exercise that entails an orientation to action. Both students and teachers used their own voice to ‘speak’ their reading of the world. Speaking the world (ibid.) appeared as a foundation for practical action towards transformation (personal, educational, social): an act of power. Discussion & Conclusions The educational practices and relations embedded in the GP course foregrounded an implicit critical approach to education and an orientation to praxis. Crucially, once these spontaneous, implicit pedagogies were manifest, it was seen that they were epistemologically developed, fostered and intentionally adopted to support the development of desired attitudes, motive dispositions, and values. The attention to establishing pedagogically sound educational practices and environments is important not only for General Practice education, but to improve future doctors’ attitude to care in all settings, primary and secondary.
Date of AwardJul 2020
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • Queen's University Belfast
SponsorsNorthern Ireland Department for the Economy
SupervisorNigel Hart (Supervisor), Jenny Johnston (Supervisor) & Gerard Gormley (Supervisor)

Keywords

  • medical education
  • critical consciousness
  • general practice
  • praxis
  • social justice

Cite this

'