Abstract
Aquifer thermal energy storage (ATES) can support heating and cooling decarbonisation, but its performance depends on hydrogeological and thermal conditions. This thesis investigates the importance of aquifer characterisation for ATES assessment in the lower Permo-Triassic Sherwood Sandstone Group beneath Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland.Data from three 100 m boreholes were analysed using borehole nuclear magnetic resonance (BNMR), optical televiewer imaging, natural gamma and resistivity logs, and pumping tests. Bedding planes, clay-rich layers and fractures were identified as the subsurface heterogeneities. Porosity was estimated using BNMR and petrophysical models, hydraulic conductivity using pumping tests and calibrated BNMR equations, and thermal conductivity using four mixing models. These datasets informed FEFLOW simulations comparing homogeneous and heterogeneous aquifer representations over ten years, alongside an injection–abstraction well-spacing analysis.
BNMR-derived porosity ranged from 2.1% to 40.4%, while Waxman-Smits estimates ranged from 1.2% to 36.6%. Archie estimates were unrealistically high in clay-influenced intervals. Standard Schlumberger-Doll Research and Timur-Coates constants underestimated hydraulic conductivity, requiring site-specific calibration against pumping-test estimates. The Zimmerman thermal conductivity model performed best against UKGEOS measurements.
Represented geological heterogeneity reduced thermal recovery efficiency under the simulated conditions. Efficiency increased from 19.72% to 36.70% in the homogeneous model and from 13.66% to 32.27% in the heterogeneous model. Heat was injected through one well and recovered through separate wells after storage. In the two-well analysis, recovery decreased with increasing spacing, with the highest recovery at 10 m. This finding does not imply optimal spacing for conventional ATES systems, where well roles reverse seasonally.
The findings demonstrate the importance of integrating geological characterisation, hydraulic testing, thermal property estimation and numerical modelling when assessing ATES in heterogeneous sandstone aquifers. They provide a site-specific basis for feasibility studies in Northern Ireland and a workflow applicable elsewhere, subject to local evaluation of aquifer properties, model assumptions and operating conditions.
Thesis is embargoed until 31 December 2028.
| Date of Award | Dec 2026 |
|---|---|
| Original language | English |
| Awarding Institution |
|
| Sponsors | QUADRAT Doctoral Training Programme |
| Supervisor | Ulrich Ofterdinger (Supervisor), Rory Doherty (Supervisor) & Jean-Christophe Comte (Supervisor) |
Keywords
- Aquifer thermal energy storage (ATES)
- Sherwood Sandstone Group
- geothermal energy
- borehole nuclear magnetic resonance (BNMR)
- groundwater flow and heat transport modelling
- hydraulic conductivity
- thermal conductivity
- porosity
- aquifer heterogeneity
- Belfast, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom
Cite this
- Standard